Dark circles are one of the most common reasons people look into tear trough filler. It's marketed as a quick way to brighten tired eyes. The honest answer is that filler only addresses one kind of dark circle, and under the eyes it comes with tradeoffs that many patients aren't told about. Here's how to figure out what's causing your dark circles and what's likely to help.
"Dark circles" is one phrase for several different problems. The right treatment depends on which one you have.
The most common cause is shadowing. A groove between the lower eyelid and cheek (the tear trough), or a puffy bag of fat sitting above it, blocks light and creates a dark line. If your circles look worse under overhead light and better when you tilt your face up toward a light source, shadow is likely a big part of the picture.
Some people have extra pigment in the skin under their eyes. This is more common in darker skin tones and often runs in families. Pigment looks brown and stays the same in any lighting.
Under-eye skin is some of the thinnest on the body. In some people, the blood vessels and muscle underneath show through as a blue or purple tint.
Poor sleep, allergies, rubbing the eyes, and sun exposure can all make dark circles look worse, whatever the underlying cause.
Filler can only help dark circles caused by a shadow from a hollow. It won't change pigment, and it can make the blue type of dark circle look worse.
That's because hyaluronic acid filler placed under thin eyelid skin can show through as a bluish tint, known as the Tyndall effect. The American Academy of Ophthalmology's EyeWiki review of filler complications describes this blue-gray discoloration and also reports that tear trough filler can cause long-lasting puffiness over the cheekbone in up to 11% of cases.
And even for shadow-type circles, filler isn't always the best fix.
Dr. David Gay is an oculofacial plastic surgeon, which means eyelids are his specialty. He uses filler in other parts of the face, but he rarely recommends it under the eyes. In his experience:
Shadow from under-eye bags: A lower blepharoplasty (lower eyelid lift) removes or repositions the fat that creates the bag and the shadow beneath it. The American Academy of Ophthalmology notes that this can often be done through an incision inside the eyelid, with no visible scar. Learn more on our blepharoplasty page.
Thin, crepey skin: CO2 laser resurfacing can thicken and tighten under-eye skin over time, which can reduce how much shows through.
Pigment: Medical-grade skincare and daily sun protection are the foundation. Light-based treatments may help some patients, depending on skin type.
Lifestyle-related circles: Better sleep, allergy control, and sunscreen won't erase structural causes, but they make every other treatment work better.
Dr. David Z. Gay is a board-certified ophthalmologist with fellowship training in oculofacial plastic and reconstructive surgery. Because he treats the eyelids surgically and non-surgically, he can look at your dark circles and tell you what's actually causing them, then recommend the option most likely to give you a rested, natural-looking result.
You can see real patient results in our eyelid surgery before and after gallery.
Yes, it can. Filler placed under thin eyelid skin can show through as a bluish tint, and filler that migrates or holds water can create puffiness that casts a new shadow.
A simple clue is lighting. Circles that change with the angle of light are usually shadows from hollows or bags. Brown circles that look the same in any light are usually pigment. An in-person exam is the most reliable way to know.
Hyaluronic acid filler can usually be broken down with an enzyme called hyaluronidase. It's an additional procedure, so it's worth getting an honest evaluation before filler is placed.
For dark circles caused by under-eye bags, lower blepharoplasty is the longest-lasting option. Pigment and thin skin are managed with skincare and laser treatments rather than surgery.
The fastest way to treat dark circles correctly is to know their cause. Schedule online or call 512-607-6884 to see Dr. Gay in Dripping Springs.